Skip to content
DecideHome
Menu
Provider review

Choice Home Warranty Review (2026): Plans, Caps, Service Fees and Complaints

Verdict: Choice Home Warranty sells a simple product: one $3,000 cap on every covered item, a flat $100 service fee and a public contract with explicit cancellation terms, in 49 states. The reasons to hesitate are the heaviest complaint volume relative to size in our set, no BBB accreditation, a 30-day workmanship guarantee in the contract and an $11.8 million Arizona Attorney General settlement in 2026 over sales disclosures.

Updated October 30, 2026 · Facts verified October 30, 2026
What we like
  • Good fit: Homeowners who want a flat per-item cap that is higher than most budget plans' appliance limits
  • Good fit: Buyers who will read the sample contract before the sales call
Watch out for
  • Not for: Homes with aging central air, where a $3,000 combined HVAC cap may fall short
  • Not for: Anyone who wants to choose their own contractor or a service fee other than $100

The short version

Choice Home Warranty, based in Bedminster, New Jersey, sells two plans. The Basic Plan covers heating, electrical, plumbing, the water heater and most kitchen appliances; the Total Plan adds air conditioning, the refrigerator, and the clothes washer and dryer (This Old House). The contract applies the same rule to everything: “Our maximum liability is $3,000 per 12-month period” per covered item, with no overall aggregate (Choice Home Warranty agreement). The service fee is $100 per claim.

That simplicity is the appeal and the sales pitch. The record around it is mixed: 79,647 ConsumerAffairs reviews averaging 4.2 stars, but 11,408 BBB complaints in three years without accreditation, and a February 2026 Arizona settlement over how coverage was described on the phone. Facts below were verified October 30, 2026; Choice is a DecideHome partner, which does not change the data or the score.

Plans and pricing (as of October 30, 2026)

Choice does not publish prices; Insurify notes it “doesn’t advertise its plan costs online,” and quotes come by address and phone (Insurify). This Old House collected nearly 4,000 sample quotes across 13 companies and averaged Choice at $60 a month for Basic and $68 for Total (This Old House). NerdWallet’s September 2025 quotes, taken without discounts, were lower: $49.17 a month ($590.04 a year) for Basic and $57.50 ($690) for Total (NerdWallet). This Old House also reports a $2.50 fee on the monthly payment option, so paying annually saves $30 a year.

For comparison, American Home Shield’s systems-only ShieldSilver averaged $36 in the same This Old House data and Liberty Home Guard posts $549.99 a year ($45.83 a month) for its Appliance Guard; Choice’s Total Plan at $68 is close to Liberty’s Total Home Guard at $649.99 a year.

What the plans cover

This Old House counts 14 systems and appliances in Basic and 18 in Total. NerdWallet, counting differently, gets 12 and 15. The contract itself lists 13 standard covered items: clothes dryer, clothes washer, built-in microwave, oven/range/cooktop, dishwasher, garbage disposal, refrigerator, ceiling and exhaust fans, garage door opener, air conditioning/heating/ductwork, water heater, the electrical system and the plumbing system including stoppages, plus 18 optional items from pool equipment and well pumps to a limited roof-leak option, external water and sewer lines, a second refrigerator and a “smart home option” (Choice Home Warranty agreement). Which standard items fall in Basic versus Total is set on your Coverage Details rather than in the agreement text.

Exclusions follow the industry pattern: pre-existing conditions, misuse and physical damage, cosmetic repairs, recalled items and items under a manufacturer’s warranty, and routine maintenance. Replacements may be builder-grade and need not match brand, color or dimensions; haul-away is not included; a cash payment “in lieu of repair” is calculated at Choice’s own discounted cost; and you cannot choose your own contractor (NerdWallet). The contract covers only one of each item unless you pay for more.

Caps, fees and the fine print

  • Limits: $3,000 per covered item per 12-month period, starting from the original agreement’s start date. Heating, air conditioning and ductwork share one $3,000 limit (NerdWallet). Most optional items default to $500, septic tank pumping to $250 and external sewer and septic lines to $1,500. In our six-company comparison, that $3,000 appliance cap is higher than Liberty’s $2,000, Cinch’s $2,000 and Select’s $500, but the HVAC figure is below American Home Shield’s $5,000 per system and First American’s uncapped systems.
  • Service fee: $100 per claim, the same for both plans, and NerdWallet reports it is charged even when the claim is denied.
  • Waiting period: “Coverage starts 30 days after receipt of the Agreement Fee,” earlier only with proof of uninterrupted prior coverage.
  • Workmanship guarantee: The agreement says work that fails within 30 days is corrected without a new service fee. This Old House’s reporting is inconsistent, citing 90 days parts and 60 days labor in its roundup and 30 days parts and 60 days labor in its review; we use the contract’s 30 days.
  • Renewal: In capitals in the agreement: “UNLESS YOU CANCEL THIS AGREEMENT, YOU WILL AUTOMATICALLY BE RENEWED TO A MONTHLY PLAN AT THE END OF YOUR AGREEMENT TERM.” Fixed-term customers must be notified in writing at least 30 days before the term ends.

Cancellation

The agreement is specific. Cancel within the first 30 days of the order date and you receive the agreement fee back less any service costs, and Choice owes a 10 percent monthly penalty if it fails to pay the refund within 45 days. After 30 days you receive a pro rata refund for the unexpired term, calculated at the end of the month you cancel, less service costs and an administrative fee of “the lesser of $50 or 10% of the unearned pro rata purchase price” (Choice Home Warranty agreement). Those are among the friendlier terms we read, and smaller than AHS’s one-month fee or Select’s $75. NerdWallet’s complaint review nonetheless lists difficulty canceling among the recurring themes, so cancel in writing and keep the confirmation.

Coverage area

49 states; Washington is the exception (NerdWallet; This Old House). Home warranties are regulated state by state as service contracts, and the agreement we read is the Georgia version; terms vary by state.

Complaint volume. The BBB profile reads “NOT BBB Accredited” and records 11,408 complaints in the last three years and 3,177 closed in the last 12 months (BBB); This Old House reports the letter grade as a B. Only American Home Shield has more complaints (18,457), on a customer base that produced 112,086 ConsumerAffairs reviews against Choice’s 79,647, so Choice’s complaint rate per review is the highest among the six companies we track. Insurify puts Choice’s BBB customer-review average at 1.03 out of 5.

Review scores. ConsumerAffairs shows 4.2 from 79,647 reviews and lists a “$500 roof repair cap” among its cons (ConsumerAffairs). Insurify reports a Trustpilot rating of 4 out of 5 without a count. NerdWallet summarizes customer ratings as “above 3.0 out of 5 on multiple websites,” with recurring complaints about long waits to schedule technicians or finish repairs, unhelpful customer service, replacement payouts customers considered too low, denials of claims they believed were covered, and difficulty canceling; the recurring praise is fast scheduling, friendly technicians and competitive pricing (NerdWallet).

Arizona Attorney General settlement. On February 10, 2026, the Arizona Attorney General announced an $11.8 million settlement with Choice Home Warranty, under a consent judgment entered January 23, 2026, resolving a lawsuit that alleged Choice failed to replace air conditioning units and other appliances advertised as covered and that its phone sales representatives failed to disclose exclusions or misrepresented coverage. The office cited more than 1,500 Arizona complaints since 2013. Choice denies the allegations. The judgment provides restitution for Arizona customers who bought by phone between January 1, 2013 and January 1, 2023 and requires changed sales practices and clear pre-sale disclosures (Arizona Attorney General). The same release notes a 2015 New Jersey Attorney General settlement of $780,000 over similar conduct. We found no comparable action against the other five companies in our set in the sources reviewed, though we did not independently confirm that none exists.

The practical lesson is the one the Arizona judgment imposes: read the exclusions and the $3,000 limit in the sample contract before the phone call, and get the plan name and covered items in writing.

How it compares

Against American Home Shield, Choice has a higher per-appliance cap ($3,000 versus $2,000 on ShieldGold), a fixed $100 fee and a smaller cancellation charge, while AHS has a $5,000 HVAC limit, a $50,000 aggregate, fewer exclusions and far fewer complaints per customer. Against Liberty Home Guard, Choice’s caps are higher on every item and its BBB grade is better (B versus D+), but Liberty backs repairs for 365 days to Choice’s 30 and publishes its prices. Against Cinch, Choice has no aggregate cap and roof-leak coverage as an add-on, while Cinch has a BBB A+ and 2,682 complaints to Choice’s 11,408. Our ranking page scores all six on the same five criteria.

Who should pick it

  • Owners of mid-life appliances and a furnace, where a flat $3,000 per item is the right size and the fixed $100 fee is predictable.
  • Buyers who value a public contract with a capped cancellation fee.
  • Not the pick for homes that depend on an older central air system, for anyone who wants to pick a contractor, or for anyone unwilling to read the exclusions first.

Sources

Sources and verification

  1. This Old House roundup: Basic $60/mo, Total $68/mo; $100 service fee; $3,000 caps; 90/60-day guarantee; BBB B; 49 states; $2.50 monthly payment fee (updated Oct 13, 2026) — thisoldhouse.com (observed 2026-10-30)
  2. This Old House Choice review: Basic $60 and Total $68 from nearly 4,000 sample quotes; Basic covers 14 items, Total 18; $100 fee; $3,000 per item; 30-day waiting period; 30 days parts/60 days labor guarantee; 49 states (not WA); sample contract linked; BBB B; TOH 4.7/5 (updated Oct 12, 2026) — thisoldhouse.com (observed 2026-10-30)
  3. Sample agreement (terms of service): 13 standard covered items, 18 optional; $3,000 maximum liability per item per 12 months; 30-day refund less service costs, then pro rata less admin fee of lesser of $50 or 10%; coverage starts 30 days after payment; 30-day workmanship; auto-renewal to monthly plan — choicehomewarranty.com (observed 2026-10-30)
  4. NerdWallet: Basic $49.17/mo, Total $57.50/mo (Sep 2025 quotes); Basic 12 items, Total 15; $100 fee charged even if denied; $3,000 HVAC combined; 30-day workmanship; auto-renew with 30-day written notice; 49 states excluding Washington; exclusions and complaint themes (May 29, 2026) — nerdwallet.com (observed 2026-10-30)
  5. BBB profile: NOT BBB Accredited; 11,408 total complaints in last 3 years; 3,177 closed in last 12 months — prod.bbb.org (observed 2026-10-30)
  6. ConsumerAffairs: 4.2/5 from 79,647 reviews (updated Oct 31, 2026) — consumeraffairs.com (observed 2026-10-30)
  7. Insurify: Trustpilot 4/5; BBB customer reviews 1.03/5; 30-day waiting period; $100 service fee; Choice 'doesn't advertise its plan costs online' (updated Dec 5, 2025) — insurify.com (observed 2026-10-30)
  8. Arizona AG $11.8M settlement, press release Feb 10, 2026; judgment Jan 23, 2026; allegations, restitution window, injunctive terms, 2015 NJ settlement — azag.gov (observed 2026-10-30)